moralitas
Saturday 15th August 2009 21:40 | A Necessary Farewell |
| that's a well written story. i can imagine that exact extract being in the series, it isnt fluffy, and all the characters are behaving as i imagine they would. a great job! |
Uzamaki-girl
Saturday 16th September 2006 23:04 | A Necessary Farewell |
| *sniff* *sniff* (happy tears) Lovely.^^ |
keira azul
Saturday 15th July 2006 15:58 | A Necessary Farewell |
| sweet story....I hope this isn't how it goes though. I'm almost certain, that in the end Ginny will be there. And Neville and Luna and maybe even the twins....but especially Ginny. Because I know the kind of girl she is, and she won't just let him take off to protect her...not when she knows she can protect him better! |
lorgbb
Thursday 22nd June 2006 22:20 | A Necessary Farewell |
| somehow i hoped that ginny would insist on going along... maybe in a sequel ? |
MercuryBlue
Friday 21st October 2005 11:17 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Dumb question--why does it say it's Pre-OotP when it's so clearly Post-HBP? |
| Friday 21st October 2005 13:08 | A Necessary Farewell (Author Response) |
| Probably because the wrong setting was selected/not changed when the
story was uploaded. Thanks for pointing that out; I've fixed it.
|
Pineapple Queen
Saturday 15th October 2005 23:09 | A Necessary Farewell |
| What a wonderful fic...makes my heart ache. I love the bittersweetness. |
SillyGillie
Sunday 9th October 2005 15:05 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Awesome job! This story was fantastic. Aww I wish you'd write and sequel to it. Where they're actually at the Burrow for the wedding. I loved Harry in this story. Brilliantly done! |
IHateSnakes
Thursday 29th September 2005 07:42 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Nice work, especially the part about how "our story will end." S |
Antonia East
Monday 26th September 2005 10:00 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Oh, that's made me feel so sad for Ginny and Harry - not that I didn't
already, but that really felt like an extension of the book.
|
ridgeback77
Friday 23rd September 2005 18:41 | A Necessary Farewell |
| That was wonderful.
|
MaxZook
Friday 23rd September 2005 12:55 | A Necessary Farewell |
| You have understood something that a lot of H/G "shippers" haven't yet figured out: that Harry has not rejected Ginny.
Good job. |
Bart
Friday 23rd September 2005 03:58 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Great Story, like Gridley I loved the "Have you ever read a book...." line.
|
Melindaleo
Thursday 22nd September 2005 13:41 | A Necessary Farewell |
| This was wonderful. I really enjoyed it. Harry's hope that Ginny had been waving to him, too really choked me up. Sigh. I'm going to keep the images from this scene in my head and just pretend it's canon, okay? |
Jner
Thursday 22nd September 2005 13:08 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Yay! I saw that you'd you updated and I had to read. Well done, as always. :) |
Gridley
Thursday 22nd September 2005 06:17 | A Necessary Farewell |
"Have you ever picked up a book..." Oh yes, yes I have. Wow.
That was an incredibly emotionally tense short. Wonderful. |
amamama
Thursday 22nd September 2005 05:27 | A Necessary Farewell |
Nice. That made a few of the unsaid things said, and Harry and
Ginny now both know that the story has not ended. Great metaphor,
by the way.
Thanks!
Berte
|
Hoss
Wednesday 21st September 2005 18:49 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Very good story. |
Lell
Wednesday 21st September 2005 18:30 | A Necessary Farewell |
| I daresay I liked this story a lot--the opening quote fit it rather well, and it's exactly how I imagine Ginny and Harry would act in that situation. Also, your Hermione was fabulously in character, and now I feel really bad for Mrs. Weasley. Also, the ending fits well with their beginning--Ginny running and waving until the train was out of sight in the first book. Kudos to that! Excellent fic. |
Mr Flibble
Wednesday 21st September 2005 17:47 | A Necessary Farewell |
| daaaawww
|
AvidHPReader
Wednesday 21st September 2005 16:21 | A Necessary Farewell |
breathtaking... the scene between harry and ginny on the almost-empty
platform... i felt what ginny felt. i happened to be listening to
a particularly beautiful part of 'rhapsody in blue' at the time and it
just fit perfectly with that scene... right out of an old black and
white movie! thanks for this, really
|
x_Rose_x
Wednesday 21st September 2005 15:00 | A Necessary Farewell |
I loved this, it was beautiful, I want to read it again :)
I think this is what is going to happen in the books though I think
it's a shame and millions of harry/ginny shippers hearts are breaking
as I say this, but I think they do have to be apart untill he finishes
it. I love the way you have written this, and it is exactly the type of
thing I imagined happening.
anyway, well done I really love this,
Rose
10/10
|
hjdevnull
Wednesday 21st September 2005 13:38 | A Necessary Farewell |
I really like this scene in King's Cross. It's perfect. There's no
overwhelming sappiness in it, but you can see the depth of the feelings
they have for one another. There's Harry's fear of personal feelings
and making plans for the future, Ginny's worry that he would still see
her as her younger self... The history they share with one another...
and all the unsaid aspects that you know Harry would never be able to
actually *talk* about.
|
Kokopelli
Wednesday 21st September 2005 13:33 | A Necessary Farewell |
| Beautiful
|
