Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For Vulnerable Veracity by gwenstarr

AlexLarsen
Friday 23rd December 2005 01:22
Vulnerable Veracity
Fic asks some interesting moral questions about war. However, as somebody who's been behind the trigger and as somebody who knows a lot of other people who have, I think you'll find the answer is, "War isn't that personal for the soldier; it's about survival, kill or be killed." I can't imagine it being any different for people engaged in combat in the Potterverse.
Arnel
Thursday 22nd December 2005 23:07
Vulnerable Veracity
Personally, I wouldn't make the choice because I love children, no matter which side of the controversy their parents support.  I think that I'd probably try to work for a cease-fire, if pressed, just to save the innocent from a life of pain.  You write of the realities of wizard war here, but you aptly describe what is going on all over the world in a myriad of conflicts.  Your work has made me think and I'm not sure I like my answers at all.  Well done!