HPWizards
Saturday 30th July 2016 06:35 | You Know Who's On First |
| Haha this was cute and funny |
DanAngelus
Friday 1st January 2016 00:53 | You Know Who's On First |
| lol that was... different |
Arnel
Monday 19th October 2015 14:37 | You Know Who's On First |
| You've done a very nice job rewriting the Abbott and Costello routine. I've read several others on various sites and I think yours holds together the best. My favorite part was Hagrid thinking Harry had misnamed him as Sirius Black. Thanks for an entertaining story. |
kori24601
Friday 31st December 2010 18:34 | You Know Who's On First |
| Hahaha that was genius! I loved it! |
Hihavaniceda
Monday 15th December 2008 04:54 | You Know Who's On First |
| OK .... that was fun ! |
gymnastgal19
Monday 8th September 2008 21:34 | You Know Who's On First |
|
alzeeb
Friday 18th January 2008 20:19 | You Know Who's On First |
| lol loved the airplane jokes |
mynameisginny
Saturday 29th December 2007 22:59 | You Know Who's On First |
| Ummm...wow. that was bad. no offence |
gymnastgal19
Monday 8th October 2007 21:07 | You Know Who's On First |
lol. nice story. original twist
|
janepotter
Monday 16th July 2007 12:10 | You Know Who's On First |
Tears...in my laughter!
A plus. O, even... |
pyromain
Sunday 3rd June 2007 08:56 | You Know Who's On First |
| this story has it's moments, I liked the part in which Hadrid said You-Know-How although it would be more logical to anser in some questions with He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named. Al in all I think this story could have been better. |
ImmortalPhoenix
Monday 21st August 2006 00:40 | You Know Who's On First |
That was funny. The beginning was funnier than the res though...
Kortnee |
Ashley06
Saturday 31st December 2005 12:45 | You Know Who's On First |
| Lol that is so funny... |
Concealed
Thursday 27th October 2005 20:06 | You Know Who's On First |
| Lovely, simply lovely. I think I died laughing.
|
Astrid
Sunday 10th April 2005 15:16 | You Know Who's On First |
| Haha, I laughed out loud on this one. |
tonks442
Thursday 3rd March 2005 16:22 | You Know Who's On First |
| Wow! That was hilarious! I love genious works like this...made me laugh out loud! Great work!
|
wokka42
Sunday 13th February 2005 22:46 | You Know Who's On First |
| Genius. Sheer comic genius. Yes, I know I abuse those words if you've seen my other reviews, but I do save those words for fics like this which are absolutely inspired. The bit where Hagrid thinks Harry is talking about Sirius is absolutely brilliant. I wonder if this kind of conversation is what Dumbledore's really trying to avoid by insisting on calling him "Voldemort"! Anyway, nice job! It's lovely being able to laugh reading a fanfic, what with all this weighty angst and saving-the-world and H/G-type stuff going on in most other fics... |
Kewii
Sunday 23rd January 2005 09:28 | You Know Who's On First |
| cute and clever
|
tante
Sunday 23rd January 2005 00:14 | You Know Who's On First |
Clever and funny - well done.
|
Shadow Hider
Friday 21st January 2005 10:55 | You Know Who's On First |
| hehehe |
belita
Wednesday 19th January 2005 17:46 | You Know Who's On First |
:D Very fun!
Airplane! is a great movie...
What kind of plane is it?
Oh it's a big pretty white plane with red stripes and curtains in the window and wheels and it looks like a big Tylenol. |
Gridley
Wednesday 19th January 2005 10:29 | You Know Who's On First |
| I'm glad you made Story of the Week - this is definately worth re-reading. I'm a fan of the original "baseball" sketch as well. :-) |
megsleeps
Tuesday 18th January 2005 22:39 | You Know Who's On First |
Very amusing.
The only thing I'd suggest would be breaks between Harry's convo with Hagrid and his dream.
However, I'm off to read your other fics, so I make no judgment yet.
To me, "This Means War!" and "Naked Quidditch" are 2 of the finest pieces of nowhere-near-canon-humor out there........and you come very close.
I do hope though, that other readers are familiar with the Abbott & Costello routine.....if they are not, they're both missing out on a great bit of comedy, and a great bit of comedy twisted from your perspective.
I might add that the "Who's on First" is one of my favorite bits of the must-read "children's" classic "The Westing Game". ;) |
Kelleypen
Tuesday 18th January 2005 17:23 | You Know Who's On First |
| Fun play on Abbot and Costello. bravo |
Pugpal
Tuesday 18th January 2005 16:45 | You Know Who's On First |
| LOL!! loved it! great job! |
pixelpixie
Tuesday 18th January 2005 05:05 | You Know Who's On First |
| that's one of the funniest things i've seen in a long time. absolutely spiff. A+. Kudos. Delicious pudding. F.A.B.
|
Thekillerpie
Monday 17th January 2005 17:08 | You Know Who's On First |
Nice little ficlet
there! Really enjoyed it. Especially liked the Police Squad/Naked
Gun/Airplane joke references in there...I've always wanted to squeaze
on into a fic, but never been sure how...you found away anyway!
Really good story...much enjoyed
|
Arnel
Monday 17th January 2005 16:41 | You Know Who's On First |
| The original "Who's on First?" comedy act has always been a favorite of mine and you've done a nice job adapting it for Harry and Hagrid's conversation. You've put a lot of thought into how to use "You-Know-Who" and "Sirius Black" to make this a very creative story. I liked it. |
Iris
Monday 17th January 2005 16:29 | You Know Who's On First |
wow, that was absolutely hilarious and a quite plausible beginning for harry potter
~iris
|
thehopefulGinnyPotter
Monday 17th January 2005 16:06 | You Know Who's On First |
| Cute. I thought it was so hilarious. |
Malfidus
Monday 17th January 2005 14:55 | You Know Who's On First |
Ahahahahahahahahahaha . . . *breathes*
Wow, that was one of the best fast laughs I've ever had . . . the way Harry Potter COULD have started. Nice work indeed. . . . :-D
|
ninkenate
Monday 17th January 2005 11:45 | You Know Who's On First |
| Very funny. I always loved Abbott and Costello. Good job.
|
Wild Magelet
Monday 8th November 2004 05:25 | You Know Who's On First |
| LOL. This completely appeals to my sense of humour, although I'm not sure that's a compliment to you! Still, I really liked reading it. Great fic, silly yes, but funny. =) |
